MUY vs MUYY: Which Weekly Dividend ETF Pays More?

YieldMax MU Option Income Strategy ETF against GraniteShares YieldBOOST MU ETF. Live data pulled from WeeklyYield.

Metric
Ticker
MUY
MUYY
Issuer
YieldMax
GraniteShares
Current price
$16.45
$15.82
Annualized yield
51.5%
63.4%
DRIP yield
67.0%
87.8%
Weekly avg payout
$0.1630
$0.1928
YTD return
-35.4%
-37.4%
Actual total return (12M)
-31.7%
3.9%
Expense ratio
1.01%
1.07%
AUM
$0.0M
$17.6M
Inception
2026-09-23
2026-04-14
Top Performer Score
13/100
29.9/100

Key Differences

MUYY currently yields more at 63.4%, a 11.8 pt spread.

MUY has stronger NAV protection based on 12-month split-adjusted price behavior (0/40 vs 0/40).

MUYY is the larger fund at $17.6M, versus $0.0M.

MUYY has the longer track record, launched 2026-04-14.

Expense ratio difference: 6.00 bps — MUY is cheaper to hold.

Last 8 Distributions

MUY Ex-date
MUY Amount
MUYY Ex-date
MUYY Amount
2026-11-19
$0.1577
2026-11-13
$0.1897
2026-11-12
$0.1505
2026-11-06
$0.1922
2026-11-05
$0.1809
2026-10-30
$0.1965
2026-10-29
$0.1530
2026-10-23
$0.2048
2026-10-22
$0.1487
2026-10-16
$0.1998
2026-10-15
$0.1583
2026-10-09
$0.2176
—
—
2026-10-02
$0.2166
—
—
2026-09-25
$0.2191

How each fund builds its exposure

MUY (YieldMax) and MUYY (GraniteShares) both aim to convert the volatility of their reference asset into a recurring cash distribution, but the plumbing differs by issuer. YieldMax funds typically hold a synthetic long position — long calls and short puts that replicate the underlying's price exposure — and then sell calls against it, distributing the premium collected each week. GraniteShares runs a comparable structure with its own strike selection and roll cadence, which is why two funds on the same underlying can print very different weekly amounts.

The practical consequence is payout shape. A premium-pass-through fund pays more when implied volatility is high and less when markets are calm, so its distribution series is lumpy. A target-rate structure smooths the payout but has to source the difference from the position itself when premium falls short, which shows up in the NAV rather than in the distribution. Over MUY's and MUYY's recorded history that difference is visible in the last-eight-distributions table above.

Total return since the longer track record began

Distribution yield on its own says nothing about whether an investor made money. Measured on split-adjusted prices plus distributions received, MUY shows -31.7% and MUYY shows 3.9%. MUYY is ahead on that basis. Year-to-date price return — the erosion component alone — is -35.4% for MUY and -37.4% for MUYY.

Tax considerations

Both funds distribute weekly, and in both cases the payout is generally a mix of ordinary income, short-term capital gain and return of capital rather than qualified dividend income. The exact split is set by each issuer's realized results and published in its 19a-1 notices and year-end 1099-DIV, so two funds on the same underlying can be characterised differently in the same tax year. Return of capital reduces your cost basis rather than being taxed immediately, which defers rather than removes the liability. Because the cadence is weekly, the tax drag in a taxable account is material — most investors hold these funds inside an IRA or other tax-advantaged account. This is educational information, not tax advice.

Which one makes more sense

MUY makes more sense if you value scale and liquidity. At $0.0M versus $17.6M, MUYY is the larger vehicle, which usually means tighter bid-ask spreads, deeper options liquidity behind the strategy and a longer record to judge. A fund with more assets also has more room to absorb flows without distorting its own option book.

MUYY makes more sense if the payout profile suits you better. It currently yields 63.4% against 51.5%, and its NAV protection score is 0/40 versus 0/40. If your objective is a predictable weekly cheque, the fund with the steadier distribution series matters more than the one with the higher headline rate.

For most investors the honest answer is that these are the same trade expressed two ways: both rise and fall with the underlying. Holding both does not diversify the exposure — it doubles it. Size the position to the underlying, then pick the wrapper whose payout behaviour and cost you prefer. Nothing here is investment advice.

Explore the issuers

View full profile
MUY
YieldMax MU Option Income Strategy ETF
View full profile
MUYY
GraniteShares YieldBOOST MU ETF